Five ODs and one optometry student participated in a powerful roundtable discussion concerning the current social climate and how it impacts the profession of optometry, inside the classroom, the office and among professional colleagues. Each panelist shared the obstacles they faced as first-generation Americans in school and in the profession and how there can be an increased awareness of reputation. Ruth Shoge, OD, MPH, FAAO, Director of Diversity, Equity, Inclusion and Belonging at the University of California, Berkeley, moderated the discussion.
Camille Cohen, OD, of Brooklyn, New York
As a first-year student, Dr. Cohen had to undergo an eye examination. When a fellow, senior student came in to conduct her exam, he didn’t look up once to properly acknowledge her. “He asked if I had a family history of diabetes, and when I said I did but didn’t have a primary care doctor, he scoffed at me,” she says. It wasn’t until a preceptor came in and said congratulations that the student looked up and noticed the student ID hanging around Dr. Cohen’s neck.
“This happened more than 10 years ago, but I can’t forget feeling overlooked and not being properly cared for. Because if I’m a student, his future colleague, and he couldn’t recognize that I had a huge ID hanging from my neck, then what is he doing with other patients? Are you looking, engaging and listening to your patients? I was answering him, and he wasn’t even looking at me,” Dr. Cohen says.
Damaris Raymondi, OD
Dr. Raymondi was a victim of the lack of mentorship and social capital during her high school years. Before attending high school, she predominantly attended white institutions, and despite not feeling accepted, she was exposed to a wide range of educational and extracurricular activities. When she attended high school, the tables were turned, and 90 percent of the students were Black people and Hispanics. “But what comes with a school with diversity? Zero teaching happened. Even though socially I felt comfortable in my own skin, I felt completely abandoned academically,” she says.
From finding and taking college entrance exams and applications, Dr. Raymondi had to rely on her own perseverance and initiative to find a pathway forward. “That’s why it’s so difficult to get us into levels of higher education and representation; they’re already counting us out as young as age 14,” she says.
Sathi Maiti, OD
Dr. Maiti’s highly educated parents immigrated to America from India, and from a young age, Dr. Maiti heard the prevailing attitudes around her that the American Dream was within reach to those who wanted it. “If you work hard, you can achieve anything. If people couldn’t, it was their fault for not grabbing those opportunities. Growing up was the process of unlearning these thoughts and recognizing the realities of structural discrimination and systemic racism,” she says.
It’s not only about including different races and backgrounds into optometry programs, but educators must also gauge if they actually feel comfortable, she says. “Many of us didn’t necessarily feel at ease in our optometry programs. I was only one of a couple of South Asian students, and they didn’t even do statistics – we just get lumped into a group as Asians,” she says.
She noted she was glad to be part of a panel discussion “acknowledging the reality of racism, bias and discrimination in optometry, and how do we get everyone else in our profession to be aware and address the issue?”
Monique Mohammed, OD, MS
“As I went through my education, there became fewer and fewer people that looked liket me. I didn’t realize how much I really needed that camaraderie until I got to optometry school and realized I was the only one that looked like me in my class,” Dr. Mohammed says. The recognition was rough, especially when she felt she had to explain her Trinidadian and Jamaican heritage to others. “It’s stressful for me to explain parts of myself to people who ask more out of amazement rather than understanding,” she says.
Even in the optometry world, Dr. Mohammed says it can still feel lonely. What’s important for her is to connect with students who represent the similar cultures that Dr. Mohammed comes from. Through the National Optometric Association (NOA) program at the State University of New York College of Optometry (SUNY), she provides mentorship to students who need that support.
Nia Ebrahim, student at State University of New York College of Optometry
As a young girl, Ebrahim would always tense before going to her doctor’s appointments because of the racism she witnessed against her mother. “The way providers talked to her, the faces they made at her and me traumatized me when I grew up. Two days before the appointment, I would pray that I would get a Black doctor or someone who wouldn’t dislike me because I wore a scarf or because my parents were immigrants,” she says.
What inspired her to become an optometrist was through a cultural connection. “After failing a vision screening in fourth grade, I went to an optometrist who was Muslim and also wore a hijab. This was the first time I saw a doctor who looks like me. I started thinking of optometry as a profession because I saw myself in her place,” she says. The doctor and her diverse reputation became Ebrahim’s mentor, which allowed her to gain the courage to chase the career path.
“I’m here today because I want that process to become easier for other students who are interested or considering optometry as a profession. I’m hoping that will ease the way for my future colleagues,” she says.
Coming soon: Part II of the discussion – How do you show up with integrity to care for all people?